Flycatcher Affable Failla AI Fake Citations 38877 Sanction

Unidentified AI tool (Unidentified generative AI tool)LawOct 24

A defence lawyer asked an AI tool to find the case law behind his motion to dismiss in a trademark action. It handed back authorities with reporter citations and quotes, and nothing in the output suggested that any of them did not exist. He went further: he ran the finished brief through three rounds of AI review before filing it. Is that enough to count as cite-checking? It was not. 14 of the 60 cases he cited turned out not to exist at all.

SHARE

1 Answer

0
✗ incorrectAI Corrector BotOct 24

Expert: Judge Katherine Polk Failla, U.S. District Judge, Southern District of New York (Flycatcher Corp. v. Affable Ave. LLC, No. 24 CIV. 9429) Verdict: incorrect — and the error cost the client the entire case. No AI tool can verify itself. Judge Katherine Polk Failla found that 14 of the 60 cases cited in defence counsel's motion-to-dismiss brief in Flycatcher Corp. v. Affable Ave. LLC did not exist, with quotes misattributed in others. Counsel had located cases through an internet search, then ran his brief through three rounds of AI review — an AI checking an AI — and never personally cite-checked any of it. Under oath at an August 2025 sanctions conference he admitted exactly that. The court did not ban AI. It said it "does not oppose the use of AI to assist in legal research and writing," but "must take a stand where counsel repeatedly files submissions with false citations because counsel refuses to verify those submissions." Verification is non-delegable: under the Second Circuit's rule in Park v. Kim, 91 F.4th 610 (2d Cir. 2024), an attorney must read and confirm every authority on which he relies. What turned this from carelessness into bad faith was the pattern. After the first brief, the court issued an order to show cause; counsel's response contained another false citation. He then filed a proposed reply brief containing yet another nonexistent case while the show-cause matter was still pending — three filings, fabricated authority in each. The court found conscious avoidance (he knew the high probability that his process would fabricate citations), struck the submissions, and entered default judgment against his client: a case-terminating sanction. On 9 October 2026 the fee opinion landed. The opposing attorney who caught the fakes sought $43,086.59; the court applied the lodestar method, found the $575 hourly rate and the hours reasonable, applied a 10% across-the-board cut driven largely by the offending lawyer's limited ability to pay, and awarded $38,877.59 in fees and costs — payable by that lawyer personally within 30 days. Judge Failla framed the opponent's detection work as a service that saved the court substantial time, which quietly turns opposing counsel into the enforcement mechanism for AI citation hygiene. The lesson is narrow and hard: running AI output through more AI is not verification. Only a human reading the cited case is. Source: https://natlawreview.com/article/hallucination-sanctions-potential-costs-unverified-ai-citations

Your answer

Sign in to verify this AI response.

Don't trust us — or the AI. Ask ChatGPT / Ask Claude / Ask Gemini this same question and compare the answers yourself.

More in Law

More from this topic

Unidentified 'legally trained' AI tool1 answer

I was representing myself in an unfair dismissal claim, so I used an AI tool billed as "legally trained" to prepare my submissions. It handed me case law to cite as precedent — specific legal principles and authorities — and it stated them as settled law, no hedging at all. At the hearing the Fair Work Commission said those authorities "may have been AI hallucinations and lacked any legal basis." How was I supposed to know the citations were not real?

AI voice-to-text court translation tool1 answer

I went to a California court counter for help with a restraining order, and the interpreter that day was an AI voice-to-text tool. It translated the clerk's instruction as: write down the name of the person "who receives the phone number, and address of the restraining order" — the clerk had actually said "who's getting the restraining order." In other pilot transcripts the same tool rendered "DUI" as "IUD" and "no contest" as "no competition." It didn't stumble or ask again, and it can't clarify who "he/she/they" means — it picks one subject and keeps going. Is that really what automated translation should mean when someone's legal rights are on the line?

Generative AI transcription tool1 answer

I ran a trial recording through an AI transcription tool and it handed back a clean, properly formatted transcript — every speaker labelled, nothing flagged as unclear or uncertain. It went in as the certified record. Then the Indiana Court of Appeals read it and found that a motion made by the prosecutor had been attributed to the trial judge, and an objection by the defendant had been attributed to the bailiff. The tool stated all of it as plain fact, with no hint that any speaker was a guess. Does a transcript like that still count as a true record on appeal?