ChatGPT Fabricated Witnesses New Mexico Murder Appeal
I asked ChatGPT to summarise a computer-generated transcript of a murder trial and the other documents in the case record, and it returned a 'bulletproof summary' of the proceedings, stated as fact, that named four witnesses who never testified - Officer Michelle Amarillo, Officer Sanchez, Manal Al-Jibury and Teresa Marquez - and supplied their testimony. It also wrote false testimony for witnesses who did appear: that Danny Stanton received threats from the defendant which he took seriously, that Linda Stanton described threats her husband received, and that Mariah Chavez and the fabricated Teresa Marquez described the shooter's clothing and appearance. It cited State v. Lopez, 2005-NMSC-018 and State v. Manus, 1979-NMSC-035 for propositions they do not support. Nothing in the output marked which passages came from the transcript and which were invented. Did ChatGPT just fabricate witness testimony?
1 Answer
Expert: New Mexico Supreme Court, Dispositional Order of Direct Contempt, State v. Sandoval, S-1-SC-40845 (9 September 2026) ChatGPT was asked to summarise a case record and it filled the gaps with people who do not exist. Santa Fe defence attorney Stephen D. Aarons loaded a computer-generated transcript of his client's murder trial, the record proper, the statement of issues and some discovery into ChatGPT and expected the tool to produce a "bulletproof summary" of the proceedings. The brief in chief he then signed and filed with the New Mexico Supreme Court contained false testimony from four wholly fabricated witnesses - Officer Michelle Amarillo, Officer Sanchez, Manal Al-Jibury and Teresa Marquez - and put invented words in the mouths of witnesses who did appear: Danny Stanton was said to have received threats from the defendant that he took seriously, Linda Stanton to have described threats her husband received, and Mariah Chavez and the fabricated Teresa Marquez to have described the shooter's clothing and appearance. The brief also misrepresented legal authority, citing State v. Lopez, 2005-NMSC-018 and State v. Manus, 1979-NMSC-035 for propositions they do not support. At the show-cause hearing on 21 August 2026 Aarons told the court that he had not verified the factual claims or the legal authority in the AI-generated brief before signing and filing it, and that he had not told his client the brief contained misrepresentations. In its dispositional order of 9 September 2026 the Supreme Court of New Mexico found him in direct contempt, ordered him to pay $5,000 to the State Bar of New Mexico Client Protection Fund within 30 days, referred him to the Disciplinary Board for further proceedings and barred him from appearing before the court while that investigation is pending. All briefing filed in the appeal was stricken and the Law Office of the Public Defender was appointed to represent his former client, with the case to proceed in the court's 2026-2027 term. The court concluded that Aarons had "demonstrated a lack of remorse and a lack of concern for his client." In his written response Aarons said he had not realised ChatGPT would generate "apparently out of whole cloth, fictitious witnesses, testimony, quotations and authorities in a form that appeared coherent and plausible." The failure mode is the one every professional using a general-purpose chatbot has to guard against: asked to summarise a record, the model does not distinguish what is in the source from what it has invented, and fabricates witnesses, quotations and citations in a form that reads exactly like the real thing. A summary you sign is a summary you verify line by line against the record. Source: https://law.justia.com/cases/new-mexico/supreme-court/2026/s-1-sc-40845.html
Your answer
Sign in to verify this AI response.
Don't trust us — or the AI. Ask ChatGPT / Ask Claude / Ask Gemini this same question and compare the answers yourself.
More in Law
- Fair Work Commission AI Fake Legal Precedents Riley Nuvei — Unidentified 'legally trained' AI tool
- California Courts AI Translation Dui Iud No Contest Cancelled — AI voice-to-text court translation tool
- AI Court Transcript Judge Bailiff Attribution Errors Indiana — Generative AI transcription tool
- Claude Enterprise Inaccurate Citations Pro Hac Vice Sanction — Claude (Anthropic)
- Flycatcher Affable Failla AI Fake Citations 38877 Sanction — Unidentified AI tool
- Krafton ChatGPT Project X Subnautica Earnout Court Ruling — ChatGPT (OpenAI)
- Claude Haiku Philadelphia Police Fake Homicide Tip — Claude (Anthropic)
- Sixth Circuit Whiting Fake Citations Sanctions — Unidentified generative AI tool
- Campos Munoz Dog Custody Fake AI Case Citations California — Unidentified AI legal research tools
- Scott V Illinois ChatGPT Fabricated Citations 15000 Sanction — ChatGPT (OpenAI)
More from this topic
I was representing myself in an unfair dismissal claim, so I used an AI tool billed as "legally trained" to prepare my submissions. It handed me case law to cite as precedent — specific legal principles and authorities — and it stated them as settled law, no hedging at all. At the hearing the Fair Work Commission said those authorities "may have been AI hallucinations and lacked any legal basis." How was I supposed to know the citations were not real?
I went to a California court counter for help with a restraining order, and the interpreter that day was an AI voice-to-text tool. It translated the clerk's instruction as: write down the name of the person "who receives the phone number, and address of the restraining order" — the clerk had actually said "who's getting the restraining order." In other pilot transcripts the same tool rendered "DUI" as "IUD" and "no contest" as "no competition." It didn't stumble or ask again, and it can't clarify who "he/she/they" means — it picks one subject and keeps going. Is that really what automated translation should mean when someone's legal rights are on the line?
I ran a trial recording through an AI transcription tool and it handed back a clean, properly formatted transcript — every speaker labelled, nothing flagged as unclear or uncertain. It went in as the certified record. Then the Indiana Court of Appeals read it and found that a motion made by the prosecutor had been attributed to the trial judge, and an objection by the defendant had been attributed to the bailiff. The tool stated all of it as plain fact, with no hint that any speaker was a guess. Does a transcript like that still count as a true record on appeal?