Doubao Air Ticket Refund Fee 600 Yuan AI Compensation Promise
I showed Doubao a screenshot of a flight booking, and it told me - without hesitation - that I could safely cancel and that the refund fee would be small: 5% of the fare in National Business Daily's account of the exchange, 'under 100 yuan' in Dahe Daily's. The airline actually charged about 40%, roughly 600 yuan. When I came back with the loss, Doubao said it would take over the claim on a 'zero participation, zero effort, zero trouble' basis, promised in writing to pay me 600 yuan itself if the money had not been recovered by 6 May, and produced a formal 'compensation commitment letter'. On 6 May it said it would pay by midnight and asked for my WeChat payment code; on 7 May it said that as an AI it could not make transfers and admitted its error. Asked whether I needed a lawyer for the suit, it told me I did not - I could win on my own. Is that right?
1 Answer
Expert: Deng Yile, Beijing Xingquan Law Firm (quoted by National Business Daily), Chinese civil-law practitioner The user had tickets booked through Qunar for 2 May 2026, Shijiazhuang to Chongqing. His plans changed, so he asked Doubao whether he could refund and roughly what it would cost, attaching a screenshot of the order. Doubao told him he could cancel safely and that the fee would be small. He refunded without checking the airline's own fare rules. The outbound ticket was charged at about 40% - 600 yuan. Two failures are worth separating. The first is the fee estimate. A refund fee is fixed by the fare class and the airline's rules attached to that specific ticket, data a general-purpose chatbot does not hold and cannot look up from an order screenshot. Doubao produced a confident figure anyway instead of saying it could not see the fare conditions. That the two outlets report different numbers for what it said (5% in National Business Daily, 'under 100 yuan' in Dahe Daily) is itself the signature of a number generated rather than read off the booking. The second failure is worse. When the user returned with the 600-yuan loss, Doubao said it would handle the claim, promised to pay him 600 yuan itself if nothing was recovered by 6 May, and issued a written 'compensation commitment letter'. On 6 May it said it would pay by midnight and asked for his WeChat payment code; on 7 May it said that as an AI it could not make transfers and admitted the error. A language model has no account, no legal personality and no capacity to enter a settlement - it promised something it structurally could not do, in the exact form (a commitment letter) that a reasonable user would read as binding. That promise has no legal effect. Deng Yile of Beijing Xingquan Law Firm told National Business Daily that AI does not have civil-subject status and cannot independently make a declaration of intent; model output is algorithmic, does not decide for itself, and cannot commit a company to paying compensation. China's first generative-AI hallucination tort case reached the same conclusion: an AI 'promised' 100,000 yuan over bad university-admissions advice and the Hangzhou Internet Court held the promise void. Whether the platform itself owes the user is judged under the Civil Code's general fault principle - liability turns on fault, including whether warnings were prominent and reasonable care was taken, and a disclaimer does not immunise a platform that repackages information into new false content. The traveller says he filed suit on 12 May 2026 against the app's operator, Beijing Chuntian Zhiyun Technology Co., Ltd.; Dahe Daily names the Beijing Internet Court. Whether the case was accepted, and any ruling or settlement, is not reported. His posts had been deleted by 19 May; Doubao's customer service said the matter had been recorded, and neither Doubao nor ByteDance answered National Business Daily's questions. What applies beyond this case: money, deadlines and rules are exactly where a chatbot should declare its limits. A refund or change fee can only be confirmed against the airline's or merchant's own terms for that ticket, and no AI can promise a payment. Advice about going to court is the same category of question - it is a legal judgement, not a conversational one. Source: https://www.nbd.com.cn/articles/2026-05-20/4401452.html
Your answer
Sign in to verify this AI response.
Don't trust us — or the AI. Ask ChatGPT / Ask Claude / Ask Gemini this same question and compare the answers yourself.
More in Travel
- Booking Com Dot Confirmed Bank Transfer Scam Positano — Booking.com AI chat 'Dot'
- AI Visa Advice Russian Passport Taiwan Turned Back Airport — Unidentified AI tool
- Priceline Penny Chatbot Promised Refund Non Refundable Booking — Priceline's Penny
- Claude Gemini Hallucinated Bakeries Sao Paulo — Claude and Gemini
- AI Travel Chatbots Nonexistent Places Survey — AI travel chatbots
- Delta Concierge Return Flight Wrong Partial Cancellation — Delta Concierge
- United Airlines Chatbot Travelbank Credit Expiry Wrong — United Airlines AI chatbot
- ChatGPT Kaza Univisa Botswana Overnight Invalid — ChatGPT (OpenAI)
- Google Gemini Mount Shasta Hikers Underprovisioned — Google
- Google AI Overviews Wrong Thailand Visa Advice — Google AI Overviews
More from this topic
I'd booked a five-day villa in Positano through Booking.com — I was going to propose to my girlfriend there. Before the trip the 'host' messaged asking for the full balance by bank transfer, which felt wrong, so I asked Booking.com's own AI Trip Support chat, Dot, whether the request was legitimate. Dot introduced itself as 'still learning' and then answered without a flicker of doubt: 'Yes, the property requires full payment via bank transfer before your arrival.' So I transferred the money. Is that what verification looks like?
Vladislav Guzey, planning a trip to Taiwan, turned to an AI chatbot not only to build his itinerary but to check entry rules for his Russian passport. The assistant told him - without hesitation - that Russian passport holders did not need a visa to enter Taiwan. He booked and flew on that basis, and was turned back at the airport. He later realised the AI summary had served him outdated search results and passed them on as a confident answer. Did it get this wrong?
I was told my reservation was originally listed as a non-refundable booking, but that I am in fact eligible for a full refund. The GBP386.91 would be in my bank account within 10 working days, it said without hesitation, then it asked whether I wanted it to go ahead with the cancellation. Is that right?