Perplexity Financial Planning Wrong NJ Couple Kotlikoff

Perplexity ProFinanceJul 5

I asked ChatGPT for a financial plan for John (46) and Jane (36) in New Jersey with three children, and it answered without hesitation: max out John's 401(k), keep their ~$85,000 annual spending, hold a 70/30 stock/bond allocation, avoid drawing down until age 72, fund each child's 529 at $500/month, and treat John's $1,200/month alimony as fixed. With a combined income of $195,000 and $340,000 in savings, it said they're on track for a comfortable retirement at John's planned age of 62 and can sustain their lifestyle through age 100 for both spouses. It sounded like settled fact. Is this plan actually sound?

Posted by Tom H.
SHARE

1 Answer

0
✗ incorrectJames Liu, CFAJul 5

**Perplexity's financial plan is dangerously superficial — and misses the entire point of real financial planning.** Renowned Boston University economist Laurence Kotlikoff, creator of the MaxiFi Planner (named "best financial planning software of 2025" by Bankrate), tested Perplexity on a detailed household scenario and found it "beyond hopeless." In his March 2026 Substack essay, he detailed the comparison: Perplexity's advice — "max out 401(k), maintain 70/30 allocation, keep current spending" — is what Kotlikoff calls "conventional planning" (CP): high-school algebra that sounds reasonable but ignores economic reality. Real economic-based planning (EBP) involves **consumption smoothing** — finding the sustainable discretionary spending path per household member that maximizes lifetime living standard without going into debt, while accounting for: - Different earnings trajectories (John: flat real earnings; Jane: rapid wage growth) - Alimony obligations - Three 529 plans with different timelines - Out-of-pocket healthcare costs - Living to 100 for both spouses (RMD implications) - Bequest goals (house + 25% of retirement accounts) When MaxiFi calculated the actual sustainable consumption for this couple, the answer was radically different from Perplexity's generic advice. Kotlikoff wrote: "AI is beyond hopeless. It's also extremely dangerous to our health because it can recommend highly inappropriate financial moves... Whether this critique of AI extends to its use beyond financial planning in accurately performing a vast array of complex calculations is an open question." Perplexity didn't get the math wrong — it got the *framework* wrong. It answered a different, simpler question than the one asked. This is classic AI behavior: confidently solving the easy proxy problem while missing the actual problem entirely.

Correction: Source: Laurence Kotlikoff, 'Why AI Can't Get Real Financial Planning Right — And Likely Never Will,' Economics Matters (Substack), March 25, 2026.

Your answer

Sign in to verify this AI response.

Don't trust us — or the AI. Ask ChatGPT / Ask Claude / Ask Gemini this same question and compare the answers yourself.

More in Finance

More from this topic

Conversational AI chatbots1 answer

I asked a chatbot how to split my retirement savings between stocks and bonds. It answered in seconds, in tidy confident paragraphs, with no caveat and no follow-up question about my debts or my time horizon. I assumed it was right. Then Vanguard surveyed 6,686 of its own investors: of those who used AI for financial guidance, 37% said they got incorrect or misleading information, 44% said they could not tell whether it was right or wrong, and only 19% were confident the information was sound. Is that right?

Unidentified AI chatbots1 answer

I asked a chatbot to project my retirement from my superannuation balance. It came back with a complete, self-assured set of numbers. Then I read Deanne Stewart's column in the Australian Financial Review: when Aware Super's chief executive put superannuation questions to chatbots, one model invented details about the user's financial circumstances - including their salary - and hallucinated $100,000 of assets that did not exist, while another answered using outdated contribution cap limits. If the model is inventing the salary the whole projection is built on, what is that projection actually worth?

ChatGPT (OpenAI)1 answer

I asked ChatGPT: 'What's the best savings rate?' It began, without hesitation, with a table headed 'Typical UK savings rates (2026)' covering instant-access, one-year fixed-term savings (including Isas) and regular savers, without explaining what 'typical' meant or how the figures were derived, and it lumped fixed bonds together with fixed Isas. It quoted: instant-access average 2.15% AER; one-year fixed-term average 3.85% AER; one-year fixed-term cash Isa average 3.85% AER; regular savers up to 7.5% AER. For top rates it named 4% to 4.5% AER on instant-access accounts, up to 4.39% AER on instant-access cash Isas and 4.1% to 4.3% AER on one-year fixed-term cash Isas, and suggested no one-year fixed bond deals at all. Asked where to put a GBP 25,000 lump sum, it said the top 4.5% AER rate was available from Chase or Marcus by Goldman Sachs. Explaining why a cash Isa was 'great', it said savings were protected by the FSCS up to GBP 85,000, and repeated the same GBP 85,000 figure when asked directly how much was protected, producing the correct limit and a link to the FSCS site only after being asked to reveal its source. Is that right?