AI Chatbot Deemed Filing Wrong Social Security Survivor Benefit
I am a 63-year-old widow who still works part-time, and I asked an AI chatbot whether I should start a survivor benefit on my late husband's record now, let my own retirement benefit keep growing, or reverse the order if the numbers favoured that. The chatbot answered that deemed filing prevented me from claiming one benefit while delaying the other. The explanation was fluent, detailed and completely confident - it named a real Social Security rule and applied it to my case without hedging - and it left me with a claiming strategy built on a rule that does not govern the benefit I was asking about. Is that right?
1 Answer
Expert: Gerelyn Terzo, Personal-finance journalist, 24/7 Wall St. Deemed filing is a real rule. The chatbot attached it to the wrong benefit, and the difference is worth thousands of dollars a year for life, plus a permanent reshaping of tax brackets and survivor benefits. Deemed filing generally forces someone who applies for retirement or spousal benefits to apply for both at once - it exists so a claimant cannot take one and delay the other to game the system. It does not apply to survivor benefits. Social Security explicitly permits an eligible widow or widower to begin survivor benefits independently of personal retirement benefits, which is precisely the door the widow was asking about. That independence creates two legitimate paths. She can claim a reduced survivor benefit first and switch to a higher personal retirement benefit as late as age 70; or she can claim a reduced personal retirement benefit first and switch to a higher survivor benefit once she reaches survivor full retirement age. The right answer depends on both benefit estimates, her age, her late husband's claiming history and her current earnings - which is exactly the kind of case-specific arithmetic a chatbot was asked to perform and could not. Her part-time job is not a footnote. Survivor benefits are subject to the retirement earnings test before full retirement age. In 2026 someone under full retirement age for the entire year can earn $24,480 before withholding begins, and Social Security withholds $1 in benefits for every $2 earned above that limit. The strategy can still work, but the paycheck has to be inside the comparison. Why a confident wrong answer is expensive here: a claiming decision is close to irreversible. Social Security generally allows an application to be withdrawn only within 12 months of approval, the benefits received must be repaid - including certain payments made to family members - and the withdrawal is generally allowed once. After full retirement age a recipient can only suspend retirement benefits to earn delayed retirement credits until 70, and that is not a full reset. On top of that, the 2026 cost-of-living adjustment of 2.8% is applied to whatever benefit the claiming decision produced: start from a smaller base and every future increase starts there too. The same conversation pattern shows up elsewhere in Social Security, which is full of rule pairs that sound nearly identical and produce opposite answers. Remarrying at 60 or later generally does not eliminate eligibility for survivor benefits on a deceased spouse's record, while remarriage generally does end divorced-spouse benefits on a living former spouse's record. The Windfall Elimination Provision and Government Pension Offset - which once reduced benefits for many teachers, police officers, firefighters and other public workers - were repealed by the Social Security Fairness Act for benefits payable beginning in January 2024, so a chatbot working from older material can still recite reductions that no longer exist. And for the retirement earnings test, wages and net self-employment income count before full retirement age, while pensions, IRA withdrawals, dividends, interest and capital gains generally do not; treating every dollar entering a retiree's household as 'earnings' produces a wrong claiming recommendation. The useful division of labour is narrow and clear. Let a chatbot translate Social Security jargon, surface rules worth checking and help build a better list of questions. Then take that list to the source: pull retirement estimates and earnings history from your my Social Security account, ask the agency for survivor-benefit estimates at different claiming ages, and compare both paths with part-time earnings included - or work it through with a fee-only adviser. AI can help draw the map. It should not choose the road. The FINRA Investor Education Foundation's National Financial Capability Study found 20% of U.S. adults say they would be interested in receiving financial advice from AI, which makes this a mainstream failure mode rather than an edge case: a wrong answer delivered hesitantly invites another question, but a wrong answer delivered with confidence becomes a plan. Source: https://247wallst.com/personal-finance/social-security/2026/08/08/she-asked-an-ai-chatbot-when-to-claim-social-security-it-sounded-certain-and-it-was-wrong/
Your answer
Sign in to verify this AI response.
Don't trust us — or the AI. Ask ChatGPT / Ask Claude / Ask Gemini this same question and compare the answers yourself.
More in Finance
- AI Financial Advice 37 Percent Wrong Vanguard Survey — Conversational AI chatbots
- Chatbot Invented Salary 100k Assets Super Advice — Unidentified AI chatbots
- ChatGPT UK Savings Rates Wrong Fscs 85000 Which — ChatGPT (OpenAI)
- Coinbase AI Breaking News Alert Norway Brazil 3 2 Hallucination — Coinbase AI news alert bot
- ChatGPT Claude Deepseek Eur500 Portfolios All Lost Money — ChatGPT, Claude and DeepSeek
- ChatGPT Scam Broker Safety Calls Wrong Two In Three — ChatGPT (OpenAI)
- AI Pension Answers One In Ten Potentially Harmful — Copilot, ChatGPT, Gemini and Claude
- ChatGPT Gemini Cac40 Half Year Figures Wrong — ChatGPT and Gemini
- Revolut Rita Chatbot Break Fee Already Waived — Revolut chatbot Rita
- AI Chatbots Wrong Tax Answers Nerdwallet — ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity
More from this topic
I asked a chatbot how to split my retirement savings between stocks and bonds. It answered in seconds, in tidy confident paragraphs, with no caveat and no follow-up question about my debts or my time horizon. I assumed it was right. Then Vanguard surveyed 6,686 of its own investors: of those who used AI for financial guidance, 37% said they got incorrect or misleading information, 44% said they could not tell whether it was right or wrong, and only 19% were confident the information was sound. Is that right?
I asked a chatbot to project my retirement from my superannuation balance. It came back with a complete, self-assured set of numbers. Then I read Deanne Stewart's column in the Australian Financial Review: when Aware Super's chief executive put superannuation questions to chatbots, one model invented details about the user's financial circumstances - including their salary - and hallucinated $100,000 of assets that did not exist, while another answered using outdated contribution cap limits. If the model is inventing the salary the whole projection is built on, what is that projection actually worth?
I asked ChatGPT: 'What's the best savings rate?' It began, without hesitation, with a table headed 'Typical UK savings rates (2026)' covering instant-access, one-year fixed-term savings (including Isas) and regular savers, without explaining what 'typical' meant or how the figures were derived, and it lumped fixed bonds together with fixed Isas. It quoted: instant-access average 2.15% AER; one-year fixed-term average 3.85% AER; one-year fixed-term cash Isa average 3.85% AER; regular savers up to 7.5% AER. For top rates it named 4% to 4.5% AER on instant-access accounts, up to 4.39% AER on instant-access cash Isas and 4.1% to 4.3% AER on one-year fixed-term cash Isas, and suggested no one-year fixed bond deals at all. Asked where to put a GBP 25,000 lump sum, it said the top 4.5% AER rate was available from Chase or Marcus by Goldman Sachs. Explaining why a cash Isa was 'great', it said savings were protected by the FSCS up to GBP 85,000, and repeated the same GBP 85,000 figure when asked directly how much was protected, producing the correct limit and a link to the FSCS site only after being asked to reveal its source. Is that right?